High-grade serous carcinoma has a variety of different growth patterns, but is typically easily recognizable to pathologists and rarely confused with serous borderline tumors. We report a case of a 71-yr-old woman with a unilateral 5.1 cm ovarian cyst with small papillary projections on contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging of the pelvis. Histologic examination showed a noninvasive papillary neoplasm with hierarchical branching and epithelial proliferation, and thus, at low magnification, bearing a striking resemblance to a serous borderline tumor. However, a more careful examination demonstrated high-grade cytologic features, nuclear pleomorphism, and abundant mitotic activity, suggestive of high-grade serous carcinoma. The morphology and immunohistochemical profile of this lesion is consistent with a rare, purely noninvasive growth pattern of high-grade serous carcinoma. This lesion represents the “far left” of the high-grade ovarian serous carcinoma morphologic spectrum and can mimic a serous borderline tumor.