Uterine leiomyosarcoma (uLMS) is a rare and deadly gynecologic malignancy. uLMS is histologically heterogeneous and presents with a wide spectrum of tumor differentiation, with a broad range of genomic DNA instability, which can make the diagnosis and prognosis of uLMS challenging. Methylation has emerged as a useful molecular tool in tumor classification and diagnosis in certain neoplasms. We initiated this study to investigate the role of global methylation in the differential diagnosis of uLMS from its mimics in correlation with pathologic characteristics and clinical outcomes. In this study, we performed array-based global methylation profiling analysis in a total of 71 uLMS and compared the methylation signatures of uLMS with several other uterine mesenchymal tumors and soft tissue leiomyosarcoma. We found that uLMS demonstrated distinct methylation patterns differing from all other tumor types. Notably, methylation profiling defines 2 distinct subgroups of uLMS with differing copy number alterations, resulting in unique histologic and clinical behaviors, further emphasized by differences in methylation pathway analysis. This study is the first to report methylation profiling as a useful diagnostic tool in differentiating uLMS from mimics and defines 2 subtypes of uLMS based on methylation signatures.