The Journal of Primary Health Care

Experience of HPV primary screening: a cross-sectional survey of ‘Let’s test for HPV’ study participants in Aotearoa New Zealand

Introduction In 2022–2023, a multi-region implementation study (‘Let’s test for HPV’) was undertaken in New Zealand primary care to inform the National Cervical Screening Programme shift to human papillomavirus (HPV) primary screening in September 2023. Aim This study aimed to describe ‘Let’s test for HPV study participants’ experiences with HPV primary screening. Method Implementation study participants were invited to complete an anonymous online survey in September 2023. Survey data were summarised using descriptive statistics. Free text comments were analysed using inductive thematic analysis. Results Forty-two percent of those invited began a survey (969/2302) and 921 were included in analyses. Respondents were aged 24–71, represented each of the three regions of New Zealand and different ethnic groups and included never and under-screened participants. Most people chose to self-test for comfort, convenience and privacy. Gaps were identified in participant understanding about HPV, how HPV testing differs from cervical cytology and the implications of HPV test results. Key topics requiring further explanation were identified by participants. Around 8% did not find self-testing easy or comfortable. Intent to screen again was high (92.4%), with greater preference for self-testing at home (48.2%) over the GP practice (33.5%). Discussion HPV primary screening incorporating the option to self-test was highly acceptable to primary care-based study participants. Despite having participated in the new pathway, knowledge gaps were evident. Clear communication from screen-takers will be key to support participant knowledge, understanding and confidence in the efficacy of HPV primary screening. Ongoing programme evaluation, including patients’ perspectives, will be essential in the pursuit of equity and progress towards cervical cancer elimination.

‘I felt so empowered, respected and shame free.’ Let’s test for HPV participants’ experience of HPV primary screening

Introduction Aotearoa New Zealand’s National Screening Unit (NSU) moved to use of human papillomavirus (HPV) primary screening in November 2023. Aims This study aimed to evaluate participants’ views on favourable and unfavourable elements of HPV primary screening and to seek suggestions for potential improvements. Method Primary care participants in a multi-region HPV primary screening implementation study were invited to complete an online follow-up survey in September 2023. This paper reports on qualitatively analysed responses to open-ended questions asking participants what they liked, disliked or thought could be improved for future screening participants. Results Of 2361 invitations sent, 2302 were delivered, 969 people consented to participate and 921 were included in analyses (40%, 921/2302). Respondents were 24–71 years of age, from three regions, different ethnic groups and included under-screened participants. Most had chosen to self-test (92%) and 28.9% self-tested at home. Three quarters shared comments about what they liked, with themes related to ability to self-test, avoiding cervical tests, choice, communication and support. Twenty percent described unfavourable aspects, with themes related to inadequate information, self-testing issues, inappropriate physical space and process and programme-related factors. Seven key recommendations were identified from suggestions about potential improvements for future screening participants. Conclusion Survey participants’ experience of HPV primary screening was overwhelmingly positive, with choice of a self-test a clear benefit for most. Inadequate information or communication contributed to suboptimal experiences for some. Participant recommendations highlight practical steps screen-takers (and the NSU) could take to ensure screening participants receive a well-informed, affirming experience that supports ongoing participation in cervical screening.

Primary care experiences in the ‘Let’s test for HPV’ study: a qualitative analysis

Introduction The National Cervical Screening Programme (NCSP) will switch from cervical cytology to Human Papillomavirus (HPV) testing as the primary cervical screening modality in 2023. To prepare for rollout an implementation study of HPV testing in primary care commenced in August 2022 in three different geographic regions in NZ. Aims This study explores Primary Care Staff’s experience of using the HPV testing pathway in the ‘Let’s test for HPV’ study so that recommendations can be made to improve the testing process before nationwide roll-out. Method Thirty-nine primary care staff were interviewed across all 17 practices in the Capital and Coast, Canterbury and Whanganui region participating in the ‘Let’s Test For HPV’ study. In total 19 interviews took place which followed a semi-structured approach. These interviews were recorded and transcribed. Template analysis was carried out on transcripts to aid in identifying themes. Results Three key themes, with additional subthemes, were identified. Staff were strongly supportive of the new testing regime. Interviewees identified some issues with the new pathway. Educational needs for both patients and clinicians were identified. Conclusion Primary care staff described the experience of using the HPV testing pathway positively; however, there were requests for ongoing additional support and nationwide rollout to be supported by practitioner and patient education programmes. With the right support this new pathway for cervical cancer screening has the potential to improve access for previously underserved and unserved groups.