John Doorbar

Role of Reserve Cells in Metaplasia and the Development of Human Papillomavirus–Associated High-Grade Squamous Intraepithelial Lesions at the Cervical Transformation Zone

Squamous cervical cancers generally arise as a result of persistent infection with high-risk human papillomaviruses (hrHPVs) and occur near the squamocolumnar junction (SCJ) and within the transformation zone (TZ). The susceptibility of the TZ to HPV-related carcinogenesis appears linked to epithelial cell plasticity, with squamous metaplasia originating from a specialized stem cell population at this site. Two alternative cell populations have been implicated: keratin (K)7+ve cuboidal cells located at the SCJ vs a more broadly distributed K17+ve cervical reserve cell population. To distinguish between the hypotheses, we utilized multiplex immunofluorescence and large-scale digital imaging to map cell populations at the TZ of 165 women with and without hrHPV infections. Our results did not reveal a distinct population of K7+ cuboidal cells at the SCJ but found instead that the cuboidal and columnar cells of the TZ express K7 and K8 throughout and lack the p63 transcription factor required for epithelial stratification. Squamous metaplasia and reserve cells, which are defined by their subcolumnar location and pattern of biomarker expression (K5/K17/P63), were conspicuous at cervical crypt entrances within the TZ extending proximally toward the endocervix. In HPV-infected tissue, crypt-entrance regions with thin high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion pathology showed prominent expression of hrHPV E6/E7 mRNA, as detected by fluorescence in situ hybridization, and p16/MCM expression, with infection also apparent in neighboring reserve cells. In some instances, normal/uninfected reserve cells (E6/E7 mRNA-ve) and squamous metaplasia were not only seen close to these regions of hrHPV infection but also extended well beyond the infected area both laterally and by depth. Our results confirm that the reserve cells underneath the columnar epithelia at TZ have the potential to undergo malignant squamous transformation via reserve cell proliferation, in agreement with previous histopathological studies. These translational findings highlight the importance of understanding the molecular biology of the epithelial sites where HPV cancers develop and suggest that in high-risk individuals, treatment strategies should target a wider area than previously thought.

The early detection of cervical cancer. The current and changing landscape of cervical disease detection

AbstractCervical cancer prevention has undergone dramatic changes over the past decade. With the introduction of human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination, some countries have seen a dramatic decline in HPV‐mediated cervical disease. However, widespread implementation has been limited by economic considerations and the varying healthcare priorities of different countries, as well as by vaccine availability and, in some instances, vaccine hesitancy amongst the population/government. In this environment, it is clear that cervical screening will retain a critical role in the prevention of cervical cancer and will in due course need to adapt to the changing incidence of HPV‐associated neoplasia. Cervical screening has, for many years, been performed using Papanicolaou staining of cytology samples. As our understanding of the role of HPV in cervical cancer progression has advanced, and with the availability of sensitive detection systems, cervical screening now incorporates HPV testing. Although such tests improve disease detection, they are not specific, and cannot discriminate high‐grade from low‐grade disease. This has necessitated the development of effective triage approaches to stratify HPV‐positive women according to their risk of cancer progression. Although cytology triage remains the mainstay of screening, novel strategies under evaluation include DNA methylation, biomarker detection and the incorporation of artificial intelligence systems to detect cervical abnormalities. These tests, which can be partially anchored in a molecular understanding of HPV pathogenesis, will enhance the sensitivity of disease detection and improve patient outcomes. This review will provide insight on these innovative methodologies while explaining their scientific basis drawing from our understanding of HPV tumour biology.

Principles of epithelial homeostasis control during persistent human papillomavirus infection and its deregulation at the cervical transformation zone

Human papillomaviruses establish a reservoir of infection in the epithelial basal layer. To do this they limit their gene expression to avoid immune detection and modulate epithelial homeostasis pathways to inhibit the timing of basal cell delamination and differentiation to favour persistence. For low-risk Alpha papillomaviruses, which cause benign self-limiting disease in immunocompetent individuals, it appears that cell competition at the lesion edge restricts expansion. These lesions may be considered as self-regulating homeostatic structures, with epithelial cells of the hair follicles and sweat glands, which are proposed targets of the Beta and Mu papillomaviruses, showing similar restrictions to their expansion across the epithelium as a whole. In the absence of immune control, which facilitates deregulated viral gene expression, such lesions can expand, leading to problematic papillomatosis in afflicted individuals. By contrast, he high-risk Alpha HPV types can undergo deregulated viral gene expression in immunocompetent hosts at a number of body sites, including the cervical transformation zone (TZ) where they can drive the formation of neoplasia. Homeostasis at the TZ is poorly understood, but involves two adjacent epithelial cell population, one of which has the potential to stratify and to produce a multilayed squamous epithelium. This process of metaplasia involves a specialised cell type known as the reserve cell, which has for several decades been considered as the cell of origin of cervical cancer. It is becoming clear that during evolution, HPV gene products have acquired functions directly linked to their requirements to modify the normal processes of epithelial homestasis at their various sites of infection. These protein functions are beginning to provide new insight into homeostasis regulation at different body sites, and are likely to be central to our understanding of HPV epithelial tropisms.

Delta-Like Ligand–Notch1 Signaling Is Selectively Modulated by HPV16 E6 to Promote Squamous Cell Proliferation and Correlates with Cervical Cancer Prognosis

Abstract Human papillomavirus (HPV) drives high-grade intraepithelial neoplasia and cancer; for unknown reasons, this occurs most often in the cervical transformation zone. Either mutation or HPV E6–driven inhibition of Notch1 can drive neoplastic development in stratified squamous epithelia. However, the contribution of Notch1 and its Delta-like ligands (DLL) to site susceptibility remains poorly understood. Here, we map DLL1/DLL4 expression in cell populations present in normal cervical biopsies by immunofluorescence. In vitro keratinocyte 2D monolayer models, growth assays, and organotypic raft cultures were used to assess the functional role of DLL–Notch signaling in uninfected cells and its modulation by HPV16 in neoplasia. An RNA sequencing–based gene signature was used to suggest the cell of origin of 279 HPV-positive cervical carcinomas from The Cancer Genome Atlas and to relate this to disease prognosis. Finally, the prognostic impact of DLL4 expression was investigated in three independent cervical cancer patient cohorts. Three molecular cervical carcinoma subtypes were identified, with reserve cell tumors the most common and linked to relatively good prognosis. Reserve cells were characterized as DLL1−/DLL4+, a proliferative phenotype that is temporarily observed during squamous metaplasia and wound healing but appears to be sustained by HPV16 E6 in raft models of low-grade and, more prominently, high-grade neoplasia. High expression of DLL4 was associated with an increased likelihood of cervical cancer–associated death and recurrence. Taken together, DLL4–Notch1 signaling reflects a proliferative cellular state transiently present during physiologic processes but inherent to cervical reserve cells, making them strongly resemble neoplastic tissue even before HPV infection has occurred. Significance: This study investigates cervical cancer cell-of-origin populations and describes a DLL–Notch1 phenotype that is associated with disease prognosis and that might help identify cells that are susceptible to HPV-induced carcinogenesis.

The human Papillomavirus twilight zone – Latency, immune control and subclinical infection

The incorporation of HPV DNA testing into cervical screening programs has shown that many HPV-positive women are cytologically normal, with HPV-positivity fluctuating throughout life. Such results suggest that papillomaviruses may persist in a latent state after disease clearance, with sporadic recurrence. It appears that virus latency represents a narrow slot in a wider spectrum of subclinical and possibly productive infections. Clinical studies, and animal model infection studies, suggested a key role for host immune surveillance in maintaining such asymptomatic infections, and although infections may also be cleared, most studies have used the term 'clearance' to describe a situation where the presence of HPV DNA falls below the clinical detection level. Given our knowledge of papillomavirus immune evasion strategies and the restricted pattern of viral gene expression required for 'basal cell' persistence, the term 'apparent clearance' and 'subclinical persistence' of infection may better summarise our understanding. Subclinical infection also encompasses the lag phase, which occurs between infection and lesion development. This is dependent on infection titre, with multifocal infections developing more rapidly to disease. These concepts can usefully influence patient management where HPV-positivity occurs sometime after the onset of sexual activity, and where vertical transmission is suspected despite a lag period.